Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Agnosticism is the greatest intellectual challenge

created by chaosmind

(idea) by chaosmind (3.4 y) (print)   ?   2 C!s I like it! Thu Jun 29 2000 at 23:46:33

Even working at a college, I deal with a lot of people who don't know what agnosticism is. Here's my standard spiel.

Okay, the Christian stands at his pulpit and pounds upon his copy of the Bible, "There is a God!" The atheist stands at his science lecturn, pounding upon his copy of Darwin's Origin of Species, "There is no God!" The agnostic points to all the conflicting religions in the world and quite humbly states, "I don't know."

But that's not a cop-out or a refusal to state a belief. Just because I merely refuse to state a belief in favor of or against the Christian God doesn't mean that I have no beliefs whatsoever, it just means I'm a little more cautious about throwing my faith to the wind.

Kierkegaard made a leap of faith towards Christianity, and I made one towards rationality, which is more of a mental practice than it is a belief system. The only real belief I have is in the Cartesian Cogito, namely that because I have thought I at least know that I exist as a thinking being.

I don't actually believe in the ontological existence of physical matter (after all, the Matrix is a logical possibility, however improbable) , but I estimate it to be of ~99.999% probability that matter is in fact real. So it's not something I really lose sleep over.

But the really difficult thing about agnosticism is the fact that you (to be truly intellectually honest) have to consider the possibility that any possible worldview might be the "one true picture of reality".

Some people think agnostics are wimps, but how tough did Thomas Henry Huxley have to be to hold on to his "highest-probable case" of Darwinian evolution over Christian creationism in the wake of the death of his five-year old son?


(Just for shits and giggles, I'm currently exploring the Australian aboriginal worldview that all life is a dreamer dreaming a dream-- and that the Christian god is merely a misnomer for the dreamer.)

(idea) by CentrX (6.1 mon) (print)   ?   I like it! Thu Mar 01 2001 at 21:31:18

The agnostic points to all the conflicting religions in the world and quite humbly states, "I don't know."

Agnosticism is the doctrine that the existence of God, or any ultimate cause beyond material phenomenon, cannot be known nor denied. It is not the absence of belief as to whether God exists or not. They are related though: an agnostic, by definition, must also state that he does not know whether God exists. However, a person that says they don't know whether God exists is not necessarily agnostic.


printable version
chaos

Welcome to the Involuntary Agnostics Association Thomas Henry Huxley Einstein: Why Socialism? cogito cogito ergo cogito sum
Atheists should read The Bible weak atheist Hume's Problem of Induction Atheist children get presents day
Not atheist, but what then? The difference between atheists and agnostics The single greatest cause of atheism agnosticism
nontheist trust fund hippie The two most common things to be found on the back of a sci-fi/fantasy novel agnostic
Spinoza's Argument for the Existence of God Cogito ergo sum Missionary Paradox Cartesian Dualism
Atheistic agnosticism The Matrix The Cartesian Argument for the Existence of God My agnostic prayer
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Nodes to live by:
Zen
Traci Lords
Pollo Bar
Mu
many-worlds hypothesis
Found: one slightly damaged happy meal toy
Islam rejects violence as a method to gain power
air pollution
freedom of information vs privacy
Mojave Desert Phone Booth
The Satires of John Donne
Dada
Integrated circuits: a technology fable
New Writeups
Ouzo
PETA becomes you, a proposed future(fiction)
Ereneta
Stone Soup, Part Two(person)
jjen
Sorrier than I ever thought I would be(personal)
locke baron
Moskva class antisubmarine cruiser(thing)
Wuukiee
May 15, 2008(idea)
locke baron
Kuznetsov class aircraft carrier(thing)
_lesra
for abby(thing)
Adaptive Child
Annie's garden salsa(recipe)
Simulacron3
Zig-Zag(thing)
Noung
Tiananmen Square Massacre(idea)
aneurin
Lord St Clair(person)
artman2003
Assholes and Douchebags: A Comparison(person)
locke baron
Tyan Thunder K8WE(thing)
locke baron
Udaloy class destroyer(thing)
Scaevola
Same-sex marriage(idea)
Everything 2 is brought to you by the letter C and The Everything Development Company