Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Debt of Tears

created by Glowing Fish

(idea) by Glowing Fish (11.6 min) (print)   ?   (I like it!) Mon Apr 08 2002 at 12:52:24

The Debt of Tears is a concept presented in the very first chapter of Cao Xueqin's Dream of the Red Chamber. It occurs in a dream that a seemingly minor character, Zhen Shi-yin has, and although it explains one of the major plots of the novel, relating it to the actual interactions of the characters can be difficult, if you don't know exactly what to look for.

In his dream, Zhen Shi-yin hears a tale of how in the fairy realm, The Stone, the sentient spirit of a magical rock, lives in the court of the Fairy Disenchanment. While walking around her realms, he finds a special flower, the Crimson Pearl Flower growing. The Stone takes a liking to this flower, and waters it with magical dew every morning, which (considering the flower is already magical) leads to the flower growing into a human form. As a fairy girl, the girl lives in the fairy realm, but gradually realizes that she owes a karma debt to the stone that watered her. She believes that the only way to repay the stone is that if both of them could be reborn as mortals, she would shed a lifetime of tears over him.

It isn't until quite a few chapters later that the major chacters in the work begin to be introduced, and it can be dozens of chapters in before the reader starts realizing the dynamic between them. And indeed, the dynamics between Jia Bao-yu and Lin Dai-yu don't become entirely clear until at least 3/5th of the way into the 2000+ page work. However, with some reflection (and perhaps a Professor of Literature to explain it for you) it is clear that Bao-yu, the petulant but caring scion of the Jia household is the Stone, and Dai-yu, his cousin who he loves is the flower. Although they love each other, and want to be together, the mechanics of family politcs (and their own problems at communicating) keep them seperated from each other, and in the end Dai-yu (who is a rather tender soul, in any circumstances) dies of heartbreak after realizing that she can't have Bao-yu. But before she does this, she cries and cries for months, giving back all the water that allowed her to take mortal form in the first place.

I think the concept is very romantic and beautiful, despite its morbidity. I have to admit that it does leave me thinking often about what exactly the relationship between myself and a few women I know could have been like in a past life that has caused me such sweet grief in this one.


printable version
chaos

What were you before you were anything at all? Blood Meridian Heart Sutra as narrative and anti-narrative Gong Gong
The Dream of the Red Chamber Lin Dai-yu karma The Violet Fairy Book
Hopeless romantic Heartbreak Terranigma Debt Of Bones
Long, the Chinese dragon Hedgehog's Dilemma Noders By The Lake: A Chicago-Style Nodermeet Stages of Grief
Instrumentality Zhen Shi-yin Inability to cry Household
romantic past life tears Xenogears
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Little presents from the Node Fairy:
Nathan, This Is Unacceptable
marijuana
A Long Week Turning Thirty
Lord of the Wasteland
Rube Goldberg
class envy
Russian Woodpecker
Mario Lemieux
John Dee
Haven't Seen Barbados
Some Ethical Issues With The Use Of Robot Combatants
Somewhere, there's a universe with your name on it, spelled out in consecutive constellations
My Angst Ate my Suffering in a Void of Meaningless Existential Nihilistic Self-Oppression: An Poem
New Writeups
Simulacron3
Sensing and Perceiving(essay)
StrawberryFrog
Bore(person)
Heitah
The Davy Crockett Weapon System(thing)
Timeshredder
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull(review)
aneurin
Miles Francis Stapleton Fitzalan Howard, 17th Duke of Norfolk(person)
Bitriot
flashover(thing)
tejasa
Cranberry Cornbread(recipe)
Dreamvirus
Brighton Bombing(event)
Ariloulaleelay
'Appendices' to a 'Report' on THE HIVE×BODY MACHŸNE(log)
Timeshredder
WALL-E(review)
sitaraika
Win-laik-pya(idea)
whitelight
The abysmalists(poetry)
Hazelnut
How to solve the obesity epidemic and the oil price hike in one fell swoop(idea)
raincomplex
Spitting out teeth like ampersands(place)
wertperch
July 4, 2008(personal)
This page courtesy of The Everything Development Company