Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Descartes' Error

created by Cermain

(thing) by Cermain (5.1 y) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 1 C! Fri Oct 27 2000 at 16:28:42

A book by Antonio Damasio which starts out with an examination of Phineas Gage and proposes the hypothesis that cognition is integrally linked to having a body (an idea which dovetails nicely with the image schema and metaphor ideas of Lakoff and his ilk.)

The book is essentially an argument against dualism, as espoused by Descartes. Damasio's argument is that the brain relies on signals from the body to prune the decision tree that it has to consider. So, I don't have to reason about whether it would be a good idea to touch the eye of a stove that has been left on for four hours - my body has an immediate visceral reaction to the proposition that tells me it's a bad idea. I don't have to waste time thinking, "Well, it would cause pain and pain is bad and it might damage the hand but it would also help warm my hand and warmth is good and..." This seems like a silly example because it is, but consider - I didn't have to weigh the pros and cons of behaving stupidly to figure out it was stupid.

Gage, Damasio argues, lost this crucial connection between brain and body and no longer had the feedback to tell him when something was a stupid idea. So he did things that weren't good for him.

Damasio provides short case studies of other neurological patients he has seen who have similar problems, and provides an informal description of experiments has has done with gambling showing that people who have less of a brain/body connection aren't as good at learning the odds of the game - or more accurately, they might learn the odds and still make plays that are stupid, even if they can describe to you why it is stupid.


printable version
chaos

Phineas Gage The Cartesian Argument for the Existence of God God is not a deceiver The Name of the Rose
Meditation III: Of God: that he Exists Meditations on First Philosophy cognitive theory of emotions Those who study philosophy
The flaws in Descartes' logic Dualism I think therefore I am Where are you going?
Spaghetti with Pecorino and Black Pepper René Descartes Biography of the Millennium decision tree
Physicalism Dovetail This ocean is angry but I might live through it Urban astronomy
empiricism feedback mathematics think
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Little presents from the Node Fairy:
There's nothing noble about being a soldier
My regret sits on the floor like someone else's polaroid photos
Saturday morning cartoon
Noders' poetry
Butter
Yoruba
Thanksgiving, suicide, and the breakdown of an already dysfunctional family
VNV Nation
Pancho and Lefty
Three times the Pale Rider came
Dorothy Parker
alphabet soup
My New Life in Another Country
New Writeups
Simulacron3
Sensing and Perceiving(essay)
StrawberryFrog
Bore(person)
Heitah
The Davy Crockett Weapon System(thing)
Timeshredder
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull(review)
aneurin
Miles Francis Stapleton Fitzalan Howard, 17th Duke of Norfolk(person)
Bitriot
flashover(thing)
tejasa
Cranberry Cornbread(recipe)
Dreamvirus
Brighton Bombing(event)
Ariloulaleelay
'Appendices' to a 'Report' on THE HIVE×BODY MACHŸNE(log)
Timeshredder
WALL-E(review)
sitaraika
Win-laik-pya(idea)
whitelight
The abysmalists(poetry)
Hazelnut
How to solve the obesity epidemic and the oil price hike in one fell swoop(idea)
raincomplex
Spitting out teeth like ampersands(place)
wertperch
July 4, 2008(personal)
This page courtesy of The Everything Development Company