Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Melody Maker

created by Electricsound

(thing) by bol (25 min) (print)   ?   I like it! Tue Sep 12 2000 at 15:01:32

Music magazine with a tumultuous history. In the 1920s, it was at the cutting edge of popular music. Unfortunately, back then this involved printing articles about "nigger music" (don't get cross at me - that's a direct quotation). It found its feet in the 60s, as pop became as wild, brilliant and chaotic as some of the writing that appeared in the magazine.

MM really hit its stride in 1983, when a junior editor, given responsibility for one issue, decided to ditch the non-entity that the reigning editor had decided go with and risk placing an unknown Manchester band on the cover. He almost lost his job for doing that, and would have if The Smiths had not become one of the biggest English bands of that time.

That single decision defined the appeal of Melody Maker for over a decade. While it's sister publication NME endorsed more conservative rock and equally conservative journalism, MM seemed to deliberately go out of its way to promote pop music and gonzo journalism. The endorsement of unknown bands continued unabated - most famously with the front page devoted to then-unsigned Suede.

Sadly, a change of editor, the lack of objectivity(almost to the point of bigotry) and the fact that most people didn't like MM's build-em-up-and-knock-em-down policy, meant that it had to change direction. It is now, in a word, shite.


Addendum 20/12/00 :
It is also now, in a word, defunct. Today sees the printing of the last ever Maker, meaning that NME is the last surviving inky

(thing) by Tom Dissonance (4 y) (print)   ?   I like it! Sun Jan 28 2001 at 20:25:42

Melody Maker's problems towards the end were several. They mostly stemmed from its ridiculously over-zealous campaign to destroy all pop music and replace it with eighty shades of grey indie wank (ie: promoting worthy guitar bollocks like Toploader and Embrace over genuinely thrilling pop music).
The problem was compounded by an inflammatory cover based on a parody of a Craig David album sleeve which featured a lookalike sitting on a toilet with a constipated facial expression, next to the words "UK garage? My arse!". The cover was rightfully attacked for its borderline racism and probably helped alienate a sizable proportion of its readership.
Thirdly, MM editor Mark Sutherland's sinister re-invention as a kind of indie fascist proved to be the final straw for many, with his policing of the letters page every week by putting down all dissenters, praising those who slated chart pop and generally saying suspect things about "our music" and "the struggle" continuing as if his readership was some kind of Hitler Youth he was trying to motivate. Towards the end it only appealed to people whose idea of "alternative" music was a Jamie Oliver compilation, anyway. It was good for so long, but just before the end, it really deserved to die.

printable version
chaos

inkies build-em-up and knock-em-down Manic Street Preachers New Musical Express
How to shoot a rock band Music journalists are failed musicians Gonzo Journalism Ode to Joy
Jamie Oliver Chronic Talent Deficiency Everett True Red House Painters
Suede Louise Redknapp Jan Akkerman Toploader
Transient Random Noise Bursts With Announcements Craig David dinosaur bigotry
NME Bob Harris Sophie Ellis Bextor Idlewild
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Nodes your sibling would have liked:
Islamic Calendar
Vincent van Gogh
integer information sample
A really good sandwich that ideath could make to take to work with her
Tell me a story about being really alive
Fragments
Charles I
Lateral Inhibition
Lumiere Brothers
A Sniper in Every Minaret
Speed exercises for guitar
Baked potato
1977 Fonseca Vintage Port
New Writeups
rootbeer277
m&m's Ice Cream Treats(review)
Transitional Man
Gus's Chalet(review)
minnow
.410 bore(thing)
shaogo
Phonautogram(thing)
Morkel
Changing your sexuality(idea)
teleny
Baron Samedi(person)
Ouzo
The Great Barbershop Race Wars(log)
Mannerisky
second language(essay)
aneurin
British Monomarks(idea)
FrankThomas
How and why do we (humans) have culture?(essay)
lee_cad
Isaac(person)
kalen
downvota(poetry)
Andrew Aguecheek
Wstfgl(thing)
ncc05
overheard at IHOP(event)
calgon
Bottomless(poetry)
Everything 2 is brought to you by the letter C and The Everything Development Company