Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Newtonian derivation of the Friedmann equation

created by siren

(thing) by siren (3.2 mon) (print)   ?   1 C! I like it! Fri Jul 28 2000 at 23:17:53

The Friedmann equation governs the dynamics of the universe.

From this equation the big bang is derived so it's nice to have an intuitive feel for the type of physics that gives rise to it. It comes out of Einstein's theory of general relativity but a classical derivation gets us most of the way there and gives some physical insight into what the equation represents.

We can consider the Friedmann equation as an equation of energy conservation.

Consider a test particle of unit mass on the surface of a sphere enclosing mass M. The potential energy of the particle is given by:

V = - GM / R(t)

The kinetic energy of the particle is given by

2T = (dR(t)/dt)2

From conservation of energy we know that

(d/dt)E = 0

Where E is the total energy of our system. If the system is conservative ( i.e. if energy is conserved)* then it can be prooven that the total energy is the sum of the kinetic enery T and the potential energy V. Luckly gravity is a conservative system so

E = T + V

so

(d/dt) { (dR(t)/dt)2 - 2GM/R(t) } = 0

integrate wrt to time and let the constant of integration = B for the moment. we then obtain the following equation:

(dR(t)/dt)2 - 2GM/R(t) = B

now the mass is just given by

M = 4 pi rho R(t)3 / 3

putting this in results in the following equation:

(dR(t)/dt)2 - 8G pi rho R(t)2 / 3 = B

which is the Friedmann equation. In order to obtain the constant B you need the full machinery of general relativity. It turns out that B = -kc 2 where k is the curvature index and c is the speed of light.

The essence of the equation is that it is an equation of energy conservation. That a Newtonian treatment should give an answer so close to the answer given by general relativity is a little surprising. The two theories diverge on small scales e.g. the perihelion advance of mercury and the deflection of light by the sun are different in the two theories. Although the derivation of the Friedmann equation gives an approximately similar answer without general relativity the Newtonian treatment would never have anything to say about curvature. This represents a fundamental difference in the two worldviews. I think the fact that the constants come out right on the left hand side of the equation might have something to do with the ubiquitousness of Gauss's theorem but that is rather a speculation on my part.


For reference i suggest any introductory text on cosmology. MV Berry "Principles of Cosmology and Gravitation" is very light and a nice technical introduction. John Peacock's Cosmological Physics gives some deep insight into these questions.
* an example of a system that is non conservative is any system with friction. This is why we have no perpetual motion devices on earth.

printable version
chaos

Fermat's Last Theorem Friedman Numbers Pythagorean Theorem Stephen Hawking
Gauss's Lemma General Relativity gauss Fibonacci
Gauss' Law Capturing the Friedmans Jerome I. Friedman de Sitter space
recursive Angband equation Abstraction
theoretical physics Cosmologist Cosmology Newton
Big Bang Astronomy
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Things you could have written:
Freedom of religion is not freedom from religion
Why time appears to speed up with age
Ye Old Lovecraftian Bake Shoppe
The Sandman Timeline
I remember when it was me who made you want to take over the world and enslave humanity
Creole / Cajun Cuisine
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
catcher
Genitive
crossover
i had a dream about the future
In a Station of the Metro
Orca
New Writeups
choirotey
Violent pickup lines(idea)
Ouzo
Blue Ovaries, Grrrrrrwl(log)
uncljoedoc
explanation(person)
Noung
One no longer loves one's insight when one communicates it(idea)
AspieDad
Pornology(essay)
nailbiter
Nicole duFresne(person)
Simulacron3
stigmergy(idea)
nakusavi
Yesterday I learned how to kiss(idea)
aneurin
UK Local Elections 2008(event)
Phyrkrakr
Kansas City Royals(thing)
niruena
Amalric of Bena(person)
niruena
Third Crusade(event)
Ariloulaleelay
I am a female android(personal)
csmith1492
Sublime Optimism(person)
etouffee
A tentative laugh, she expected to be interrupted(poetry)
This affordable entertainment brought to you by The Everything Development Company