How to test if a knife is sharp

(idea) by PowderedTOASTMan (2.5 y) (print) ? 1 C! I like it! Mon Apr 29 2002 at 7:20:17

There are numerous ways to test if your knife is sharp. This writeup mainly refers to kitchen knives, though you can also try these techniques on your bayonet/bayonnette, bowie knife, hunting knife, Swiss Army Knife etc.

1) One of the safest and most effective ways requires a ripe tomato (or a piece of tomato) with its skin on. All you do is place the sharp edge of the blade of the knife against the skin of the tomato and gently cut. Do not use any downward pressure on the knife other than the weight of the blade itself. Move the knife fowards or backwards about 1cm or so (half an inch) and if the knife actually cuts the tomato's skin, then your knife is sharp. This is a very handy method if you happen to be cooking something that involves tomatoes at the time. A blunt knife will just press/mash the tomato.

2) Slightly more dangerous, but the method I prefer, and from what I gather many culinary professionals use this method too. Do the tomato test on your thumbnail. Only move the blade a very small distance (half a centimetre, 1/8th of an inch) and if the knife "sticks" or "catches" in your thumbnail, then your knife is sharp. A blunt knife will just slide across your thumbnail and won't cut. PLEASE BE CAREFUL with this one folks. Use virtually no downward pressure and only move the knife the tiniest distance. Be aware that some knives will have sharp and blunt areas, so if you zing across your thumbnail with a knife that you *think* is totally blunt, you may be in for a nasty surprise.

3) Cutting a piece of paper. Favoured by a lot of samurai movies I have seen, just take a piece of paper (rice paper if you're a samurai, photocopier/printer paper if you're in the office), hold it by one edge only, and use your knife to cut downwards on the free edge. A sharp knife will cut, a blunt knife will not. This not the best method, as even fairly cruddy knives can achieve a cut.

4) Shaving your arm. Not the best method, a fairly blunt knife will shave you if you cut with the grain of your hair. Other disadvantages are:

The requirement of hairy arms/hands.

A small bald-patch on your arm.

Hair all over your knife.
I've also heard stories about teachers/employers/counsellors seeing bald patches on peoples arms from testing knives and assuming they are deranged psychos, then sending them off to counselling.

5) Shaving your face.
Advantage:

You look really cool and manly like Crocodile Dundee
Disadvantages:

Only works if you have facial hair.

Hurts, can leave shaving rash.

Will blunt your knife.

End up with whiskers/shaving cream all over your knife.

6) Just use it.
If you use your knife enough, you'll end up being able to tell just from using it whether it is sharp or not. If it isn't, just grab your sharpening steel and give it a few slides. Many professional butchers/cooks don't even bother with any of the above methods, they just know by the feel of how their knife is performing.

(idea) by PaulM (2.1 y) (print) ? I like it! Mon Sep 09 2002 at 9:32:10

If you do not have a tomato or piece of paper handy (which some reckon, will help blunt a knife designed for cutting other things) and don't want to shave patches off your arm (ditto) or risk slicing your thumb(nail) in two then it is possible to test the sharpness of a knife safely using only your thumb, as long as you remember this golden rule:

Never rub your finger ALONG the edge of a blade - rub it ACROSS it.

. The easiest way to do it is to turn the knife upside down then move your thumb across the blade once in a side to side motion. You are testing to see how thin that edge is where thin equals sharp. You should soon find it easy to gauge the sharpness of a knife without risk to life or limb.

printable version
chaos

How to win a knife fight	The Appendix Incident	edev: Writeuptype bugs, or how nate got stuck between two parentheses	How to make a knife
How to sharpen a knife	Selection and care of kitchen knives	Bowie knife	Obviously, Doctor, you've never been a thirteen year-old girl
How to peel a pineapple	kukri	Amusing comments in source code	Swiss Army Knife
Crocodile Dundee	knife	Bayonet	butterfly knife
The sound of rain on a corrugated steel roof	Smegma	Little numbers on a piece of paper	How a Pope is chosen
I have a good idea, smear crap on your face	Knife control	There is no answer; there is no question	Butterfinger

Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.

Login
Password

remember me
password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Look at this mess the Death Borg made!
Thomas Jefferson's First Inaugural Address
Grand Rapidians - Part One
jeepney
The Wandering Jew
Trinket
Starship Troopers
Soul Train
The Phantom of the Opera
Terror and Liberalism
Aesop's Fables
pear
Aerosmith
And you as well must die, beloved dust,

nailbiter
nerve stapling	(thing)
locke baron
Multiple Myeloma	(thing)
SubSane
blonde, freckles, skinny, short	(person)
arcanamundi
A Ruba'iyat for May	(person)
riverrun
Timed Writing	(idea)
auraseer
Fling	(fiction)
StrawberryFrog
Iron Man	(review)
devolution
Misogyny and Porn, East to West - An Empirical Analysis	(idea)
devolution
Korea is a place that refuses to stand still	(idea)
Beanie127
The Pacifist Soldier	(fiction)
VergilKint
Distilled from Dreams	(fiction)
Scaevola
Roman marriage	(thing)
rootbeer277
m&m's Ice Cream Treats	(review)
Transitional Man
Gus's Chalet	(review)
minnow
.410 bore	(thing)

E2 is a by-product of the existence of The Everything Development Company