Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Catenary

created by Webster 1913

(thing) by vireo (3.9 y) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 1 C! Mon Mar 12 2001 at 1:03:45

The catenary curve, often called chainette and sometimes alysoid, has the following parametric equation:

y = (a/2)(exp(x/a)+exp(-x/a))

or, equivalently,

y = a cosh(x/a)

where "cosh" denotes the hyperbolic cosine. As mentioned in the Webster, this is the curve taken by a homogenous, flexible and inextensible chain hanged by its two extremities. Galileo thought this curve would be a parabola; in 1690, Jakob Bernouilli challenged his colleagues to find the exact mathematical expression, and in 1691, Leibniz, Huygens and Johann Bernouilli all found independently the answer to this question. The catenary curve is the solution to the following differential equation:

y'' = (m/c) sqrt(1+y'2)

which describes the condition for static equilibrium, m being the mass density of the chain and c the tension along the horizontal direction. Follow "A hanging string forms a hyperbolic cosine curve" for a complete demonstration... It is interesting to note that when a parabola is rolling on a line, the path followed by the focus is a catenary.

Primary source: www.2dcurves.com


(thing) by ssd (7.2 mon) (print)   ?   (I like it!) Sun May 13 2001 at 13:25:18

If you hold the ends of a rope and let it sag down between, it forms a catenary curve. Imagine holding that curve stiff and flipping it over, so it points up. You now have a catenary arch. The sides of the catenary arch are self supporting, reducing the forces on the keystone. The gateway arch in St. Louis is a catenary arch.

(thing) by morven (2.6 y) (print)   ?   (I like it!) Wed Mar 05 2003 at 0:15:55

The style of overhead wire used by many electric railways is often referred to as catenary, because it contains a roughly catenary curve. The wire that takes this form is called the messenger wire and it is loosely hung between widely spaced suspension points. From this messenger wire hang drop wires of varying lengths connect to the contact wire which is as near smoothly horizontal as can be achieved. This is known as catenary suspension and is utilised because it allows the contact wire to be kept relatively straight and horizontal while permitting quite wide spacing of supports.

In some applications, another wire, the auxilary wire, is above and parallel to the contact wire, attached to it at regular and close intervals. The purpose of this wire is that it contains more copper than the others, allowing for better electrical conductivity. The added copper makes it softer, which would not be desirable in either the messenger wire or contact wire, for reasons of strength and wear resistance; the addition of an extra wire which is neither load bearing nor touched by the locomotives' pantographs enables better conductivity without compromise.

It has become common to refer to the whole arrangement as 'catenary', even though only the messenger wire describes a catenary curve; moreover, lazy usage has seen the term 'catenary' used to describe all overhead wire systems, even those that use no catenary curve at all!


(thing) by metalangel (6.7 d) (print)   ?   (I like it!) Thu Mar 27 2003 at 1:35:31

An interesting fact about catenary is that the supports which hold the wire are arranged to vary in distance every other post. So one long, one short, one long. Granted, the difference in these distances is mere inches but it is meant to encourage smooth, more even contact with the pantograph of passing trains. This also ensures more dispersed wear on the contact portion of the pantograph itself - as the wire is constantly moving laterally the chance of making a trough in the metal is greatly reduced.

The tension is also kept up by way of large counterweights, usually hung from one of the supports, to ensure the wire won't droop (pantograph height is a precise thing). When this is done, the catenary is divided into sections. One wire will join the existing wire from an addition support, and the two will run parallel. After passing another support or two, the first wire will then run off to one side to either terminate or attach to the counterweight, while the second is now the power supply wire. This ensures uninterupted power for the train (otherwise you'd have that subway syndrome where the lights go off in the car as it passes over a switch where there's no third rail). This sometimes is how section breaks are isolated, in addition to being a convenient way to keep the wires up!

Edit: I've now discovered, in the UK at least, that the side-to-side movement of the wire is 50cm


(definition) by Webster 1913 (print) Tue Dec 21 1999 at 22:23:29

Cat"e*na*ry (?), Cat`e*na"ri*an (?), a. [L. catenarius, fr. catena a chain. See Chain.]

Relating to a chain; like a chain; as, a catenary curve.

 

© Webster 1913.


Cat"e*na*ry, n.; pl. Catenaries (). Geol.

The curve formed by a rope or chain of uniform density and perfect flexibility, hanging freely between two points of suspension, not in the same vertical line.

 

© Webster 1913.


(thing) by snol (5 y) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 1 C! Sun Dec 24 2000 at 0:25:58

The curve made by a hanging string can be modeled by considering the gravitational and tensile forces acting on an infinitesimal segment of the string. This segment, of length dL, has weight (mass per unit length)*(gravitational acceleration)*dL - we'll take mass per unit length as a constant and define

q = (mass per unit length)*(gravitational acceleration).

In many problems you can assume that the tension is constant over the length of the string, but when the string's own mass is in consideration in the problem you can no longer do this, as we'll see. So we'll say that, over the length dL, the tension on the string changes from T to T+dT. We'll also say that the angle the string makes with the horizontal goes from A to A+dA.

Now since this segment of string is immobile (i.e. it has no acceleration), all forces on it must cancel each other. We'll balance the forces of tension and gravity in the horizontal, then the vertical direction.

In the horizontal direction the only forces we have are the tensions on each end. Tension, by definition, is a force pointing in the same direction as the string does. The horizontal component of the tension therefore involves the cosine of the string's angle with the horizontal. The force equation is this:

Fhoriz = 0 = -T cos(A) + (T+dT) cos(A+dA)

The addition rule for the cosine is

cos(x+y) = cos(x) cos(y) - sin(x) sin(y)

so

cos(A+dA) = cos(A) cos(dA) - sin(A) sin(dA) = cos(A) - dA sin(A)

Here we took the first-order approximations for trig functions of small angles: the cosine of a small angle equals one and the sine of a small angle equals the angle itself. Now back in our force equation we have

0 = -T cos(A) + T cos(A) + dT cos(A) - T dA sin(A) - dT dA sin(A)

The first two terms cancel and the last term, with the product of two infinitesimals, is negligible compared to the other remaining terms, leaving us with

dT cos(A) = T dA sin(A)

(Incidentally, this is where things would fall apart if we took T to be constant over the whole string:
we'd have only 0 = T dA sin(A), leaving us puzzled as to which of those factors is supposed to always be zero.)
Separating the two variables,

dT/T = tan(A) dA

Integrating both sides

ln(T) = -ln(abs(cos(A))) + C

T = CT sec(A)

In the last step we took the exponential of both sides, cancelling the logarithms and redefined the integration constant so that it'd be proportional to the tension. This constant basically just depends on how the string is hung.

Now in the vertical direction, we have gravity as well as tension:

Fhoriz = 0 = -q dL - T sin(A) + (T+dT) sin(A+dA)

We'll again expand according to the addition rule for the sine:

sin(x+y) = sin(x)cos(y) + cos(x)sin(y)

Using the first-order approximations again, this gives

0 = -q dL - T sin(A) + T sin(A) + dT sin(A) + T dA cos(A) + dT dA cos(A)

Cancelling and removing the negligible double-infinitesimal term we get

q dL = dT sin(A) + T dA cos(A)

Now we'll substitute in the solution we obtained for the tension. Differentiating, we have

dT = CT tan(A) sec(A) dA

so

q dL = CT tan2(A) dA + CT dA = CT dA (tan2(A) + 1)

so

q dL = CT sec2(A) dA

At this point we could solve this differential equation and obtain the inclination angle as a function of length along the string. But to find the shape of the actual curve that the string forms, it's better to substitute Cartesian coordinates. A and dL are both definable in terms of differentials of Cartesian coordinates:

A = tan-1(dY/dX)

so

dA = cos2(tan-1(dY/dX)) d(dY/dX)

(look it up in a table of derivatives if you don't believe me... ) and

dL = sqrt((dX)2 + (dY)2) = sqrt(1 + (dY/dX)2) dX

We'll define the slope dY/dX as a new variable S for notational convenience and take X as the independent variable. Our new force equation is this:

q sqrt(1+S2) dX = CT sec2(tan-1(S)) cos2(tan-1(S)) dS

The cosines and secants nicely cancel, leaving

(q/CT) dX = dS/sqrt(1+S2)

The nicest way to integrate the right half of this equation is to substitute a hyperbolic sine for S. The hyperbolic sine and cosine have the properties that each one is the derivative of the other and

cosh2(a) - sinh2(a) = 1

so

sqrt(1+sinh2(a)) = cosh(a)

So if we substitute S = sinh(a) we get

dS/sqrt(1+S2) = cosh(a) da/cosh(a) = da

This leaves the equation, after integration and resubstitution, as a fairly simple

(q/CT) X = sinh-1(dY/dX) + CX

sinh((q/CT) X - CX) dX = dY

As noted before, the hyperbolic cosine and sine are each other's derivatives, so the integral is simple and leaves us with an expression for the curve the string forms in Cartesian coordinates:

Y = (CT/q) cosh((q/CT) X - CX) + CY


See any mistakes? message me.
Know of a better way to format math in e2? message me also.

printable version
chaos

There is no 'I' in 'team' Gateway Arch zip line catenoid
Third rail Pantograph section break overhead wire
Jefferson National Expansion Memorial hyperbola Evan Dorkin Tide World
TOPS phase break A problem ordering beer in San Diego keystone
Static Equilibrium Mitral valve prolapse cosh parametric
Curve Maxwell's Equations hyperbolic cosine Helicoid
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Just another sprinkling of indeterminacy
Kicking up leaves as we walk along
Network
Hakuin and the Baby
Bigfoot
How to make a car last nearly forever
Seven Wonders of the Ancient World
Guessing the worth of something
Airport security
water
Valentine Baker
The Big Bang as the origin of matter
Everything Rumors
Reflections of yourself
New Writeups
Augustine
Vanya on 42nd Street(review)
tentative
Chances Not Taken(idea)
Heitah
Why I love Everything2(person)
trixingee
Dungeon Mastering for the first time(idea)
Netrat0
It's Called Subtext, Honey(person)
eyeofthebeholder
The Dragon(idea)
Heitah
consist, comprise, constitute, or compose(idea)
Meezzio
Gotlandssnus(thing)
argv
Astral Plane(idea)
Madara
One Winged Angel(fiction)
Tom Rook
Talk is cheap(poetry)
shaogo
Adelle Davis(person)
Aerobe
race car g sfjsgsd(poetry)
Binah
Dream Log: July 5, 2008(dream)
StrawberryFrog
Forgotten things in space(idea)
This affordable entertainment brought to you by The Everything Development Company